Category Archives: California

Simi Valley, CA reminder: Council to consider BS-MSN, March 26

Simi Valley city council will consider breed-specific mandatory spay/neuter for all “pit bull”-looking dogs, March 26, 6:30 PM, at City Hall, 2929 Tapo Canyon Road.

City of Simi Valley Mayor and City Council
bhuber@simivalley.org; bwilliam@simivalley.org; gbecarra@simivalley.org; ssojka@simivalley.org; mjudge@simivalley.org   

Please encourage the city of Simi Valley to drop the breed-specific language in their proposal. Breed-specific MSN—like any other breed-specific law—discriminates against people and their dogs based on whether the owner or dog have a “desirable” or “undesirable” physical appearance. Breed identification is a subjective, non-scientific process, which results in unfair and unequal application of the law. Disputes over breed identification are also inevitable, and appeals and court cases fighting breed designations are expensive and resource-consuming.

StopBSL takes no position on mandatory spay/neuter as long as it is not breed-specific. Whether you support or oppose MSN, it doesn’t need to be breed-specific. If MSN is good for dogs that look like “pit bulls,” it is good for any dog. By removing the breed-specific focus, the city of Simi Valley can avoid the expense and inequality that goes with BSL.

All alerts for Simi Valley: http://stopbsl.com/?s=simi+valley

Simi council to consider pit bull ordinance

By Mike Harris
Posted March 25, 2012 at 8:23 p.m.

The Simi Valley City Council today will consider an ordinance that would require residents to spay or neuter their pit bulls. [...]

Diane Rowley Van Sickle, president of the Santa Paula Animal Rescue Center and director of Promote and Protect Animals, expressed her opposition to the proposal in a March 7 letter to the Simi Valley council.

“The better, less arbitrary and prejudicial ordinance would be one that requires all dogs brought in as strays be altered for free as a condition of return to the owner unless the owner can produce (American Kennel Club) papers and a breeders’ license or a statement by a vet saying the dog is already sterile, or too old, too young or too sick to undergo the operation,” she wrote. [...]

Full article retrieved 3/26/12 from: http://www.vcstar.com/news/2012/mar/25/simi-council-to-consider-pit-bull-ordinance/

City of Ventura, CA: Council moves forward with BS-MSN

The city of Ventura is putting together a breed-specific mandatory spay/neuter ordinance for “final approval” at an upcoming council meeting. This BS-MSN will target dogs that look like “pit bulls.”

Please encourage the city of Ventura to drop the breed-specific language in their proposal. Breed-specific MSN—like any other breed-specific law—discriminates against people and their dogs based on whether the owner or dog have a “desirable” or “undesirable” physical appearance. Breed identification is a subjective, non-scientific process, which results in unfair and unequal application of the law. Disputes over breed identification are also inevitable, and appeals and court cases fighting breed designations are expensive and resource-consuming.

StopBSL takes no position on mandatory spay/neuter as long as it is not breed-specific. Whether you support or oppose MSN, it doesn’t need to be breed-specific. If MSN is good for dogs that look like “pit bulls,” it is good for any dog. By removing the breed-specific focus, the city of Ventura can avoid the expense and inequality that goes with BSL.

City of Ventura Mayor and City Council
mike.tracy@cityofventura.net, cheitmann@ci.ventura.ca.us, nandrews@ci.ventura.ca.us, bbrennan@ci.ventura.ca.us, jmonahan@ci.ventura.ca.us, cmorehouse@ci.ventura.ca.us, cweir@ci.ventura.ca.us

Ventura moves to require spaying and neutering of pit bulls

By Arlene Martinez
Posted March 7, 2012 at 4:08 p.m.

Starting this year, pit bull owners in Ventura will have to get their dogs spayed or neutered by the time the animals are 4 months if the City Council gives an expected final approval to a measure. [...]

The Ventura City Council voted Monday to direct staff to prepare the ordinance for final approval. The county hopes every city adopts the ordinance so it can begin enforcing it.

The shelter defines “pit bull” as a Staffordshire Bull Terrier, American Pit Bull Terrier or American Staffordshire Terrier. The ordinance exempts purebreds registered with the American Kennel Club, United Kennel Club or “other national registry” dogs that may be too sick or injured to be neutered. Dogs used in law enforcement also are exempt. [...]

Full article retrieved 3/8/12 from http://www.vcstar.com/news/2012/mar/07/ventura-takes-lead-in-supporting-pit-bull/

All alerts for Ventura (county and cities): http://stopbsl.com/?s=ventura

Ventura County, CA: Cities take up issue of breed-specific MSN

Many thanks to Jodi for this concise write-up!

http://blessthebullys.wordpress.com/2012/03/05/change-the-course-of-breed-specific-proposal-in-ventura-county-california/

In January, the Ventura County Animal Services Commission approved a mandatory spay/neuter proposal that would apply only to “pit bulls”. That proposal was sent to city governments and county leaders for consideration in coming weeks.

It appears there are many divisions among city leaders with respect to the proposal, and we may have an opportunity to change its course. The cities of Ventura, Oxnard, and Simi Valley, California are scheduled to address the proposed ordinance by the end of March. In April, the commission will discuss the proposal again, and if a majority of cities in the county have approved it, the measure will go before the supervisors.

Regardless of your position on spaying and neutering of pets, it is important to remember that any law that applies to one breed or grouping of dogs involves the practice of breed profiling and is breed specific legislation. Breed specific MSN is fraught with the many problems associated with BSL, and opens the door for future additional breed restrictions.

Please contact the city council members of these cities and encourage them to seek a solution that does not single out one breed of dog. Suggested alternatives can be found at: http://tinyurl.com/6v4j4yy

City of Ventura Mayor and City Council
mike.tracy@cityofventura.net, cheitmann@ci.ventura.ca.us, nandrews@ci.ventura.ca.us, bbrennan@ci.ventura.ca.us, jmonahan@ci.ventura.ca.us, cmorehouse@ci.ventura.ca.us, cweir@ci.ventural.ca.us

City of Oxnard Mayor and City Council
drtomholden@aol.com, irene.pinkard@ci.oxnard.ca.us, bryan.macdonald@ci.oxnard.ca.us, timbflynn@gmail.com, carmen4oxnard@gmail.com

City of Simi Valley Mayor and City Council
bhuber@simivalley.org, bwilliam@simivalley.org, gbecarra@simivalley.org, ssojka@simivalley.org, mjudge@simivalley.org

All alerts for Ventura County: http://stopbsl.com/?s=ventura+county

Pit bull spay proposal drawing mixed support among cities

By Hannah Guzik, Ventura County Star
Posted March 3, 2012

An ordinance proposing mandatory spaying and neutering of pit bull terriers countywide is drawing mixed support even as Ventura County Animal Shelter workers say the policy would reduce euthanasia rates.

The Ventura County Animal Services Commission approved the proposal in January, sending it to city governments and county leaders for consideration in coming weeks.

The commission hopes each city council and the Ventura County Board of Supervisors will adopt the ordinance. If the proposal doesn’t win approval across the board, it will be difficult to enforce, said Monica Nolan, animal services director at the shelter in Camarillo.

Read more: http://www.vcstar.com/news/2012/mar/03/pit-bull-spay-proposal-drawing-mixed-support/#ixzz1oCO6Ipin

Ventura County, CA: Breed-specific MSN proposal approved by commission

The Ventura County Animal Regulation Commission has unanimously voted in support of mandatory spay/neuter for all ”pit bulls.”

[...] The commission, made up of elected officials from the Ventura County Board of Supervisors and city councils, unanimously voted to support a mandatory spay-neuter policy for pit bulls, which means each city and the county will consider such an ordinance.

If the ordinances are adopted as proposed, owners of any of the three terrier breeds commonly referred to as pit bulls would get what amounts to a “fix-it ticket” if they are discovered with an unaltered adult dog. [...]

Full article retrieved 1/28/12 from http://www.vcstar.com/news/2012/jan/26/activists-push-for-no-kill-animal-shelter/

Remember, breed-specific mandatory spay/neuter (BS-MSN) is based on appearance alone, and is as flawed, unequal, and subjective as any other law that is based on what a dog “looks like.” It is entirely up to an animal control official, based on his or her subjective visual assessment of your dog’s physical appearance, to determine whether you and your dog fall under this ordinance.

The ordinance presumably now goes to the county board, and all of the city councils within the county, for consideration. Because there are now so many areas to watch with respect to this issue, and because we do not know whether or when the cities will consider the ordinance, we would definitely appreciate assistance from locals who are able to monitor the agendas in these areas and alert us if the issue comes up for discussion.
Ventura County Board of Supervisors
Cities: Ojai, Fillmore, Santa Paula, Moorpark, Ventura, Camarillo, Simi Valley, Thousand Oaks, Oxnard, Port Hueneme

All alerts for Ventura County: http://stopbsl.com/?s=ventura+county

Ventura County, CA: Breed-specific MSN proposal to be discussed, Jan 26

Back in August 2011, Ventura County Animal Services director Monica Nolan said she would introduce an ordinance to mandate spay/neuter for all “pit bulls” in the county. A draft proposal will be brought forward for discussion and direction at the next meeting of the Animal Regulation Commission.

The Animal Regulation Commission will meet on January 26 at 9:00 AM at the Camarillo Animal Shelter, 600 Aviation Drive, Camarillo, CA. Click here for the current agenda: http://portal.countyofventura.org/portal/page/portal/animalreg/AnimalRegulationCommission/
The mandatory “pit bull” spay/neuter proposal is item 4.
Item 5, a discussion about how to reduce shelter killing, increase adoptions, and achieve no-kill status, is another important topic that may affect the commission’s decisions about the BS-MSN proposal.

If you are local to Ventura County, please attend this meeting and show your opposition to breed-specific laws. Remember, breed-specific mandatory spay/neuter (BS-MSN) is breed-specific, and is as flawed, unequal, costly, and subjective as any other law that is based on what a dog “looks like.”

These were the members of the Animal Regulation Commission as of May 2011. Many of the members are councilmembers of the cities within Ventura County. We do not know where they stand on BS-MSN, so please be respectful when you correspond with them.
Kevin Kildee, council@ci.camarillo.ca.us
Brian Sipes, loansbyBrian@msn.com
Janice Parvin, JParvin@ci.moorpark.ca.us
Carlon Strobel, Strobel@ci.ojai.ca.us
Dr. Irene G. Pinkard, Irene.pinkard@ci.oxnard.ca.us
Jonathan Sharkey, Jon@sharkey.com
Rick Cook, calwestrickcook@verizon.net
Barbra Williamson, Simivalleygal@gmail.com
James Monahan, jmonahan@ci.ventura.ca.us

Email block for cut-and-paste
council@ci.camarillo.ca.us; loansbyBrian@msn.com; JParvin@ci.moorpark.ca.us; Strobel@ci.ojai.ca.us; Irene.pinkard@ci.oxnard.ca.us; Jon@sharkey.com; calwestrickcook@verizon.net; Simivalleygal@gmail.com; jmonahan@ci.ventura.ca.us

The BS-MSN proposal has not been publicized in the news media for six months, the animal commission hasn’t met for seven months, and the online meeting agenda is difficult to find if you don’t know where to look (or have no reason to look). Due to the lack of official action on this issue since last summer, StopBSL had removed Ventura County from the BSL watchlist.

We sincerely appreciate the contribution of an anonymous site visitor who alerted us to this new meeting information! Ventura County is another case where we are extremely grateful for locals who are able to get us necessary details that we would not get elsewhere.

All alerts for Ventura County: http://stopbsl.com/?s=ventura+county

Petaluma, CA: Breed-specific MSN proposal rejected

One of the Petaluma Animal Services Advisory Committee members asked that the committee consider mandatory spay/neuter for “pit bulls.” Last night, the committee voted 6-1 against breed-specific MSN. The issue probably will not come up again in the foreseeable future.

Thank you to Gabe Kearney, Petaluma City Councilman and member of the Animal Services Board, for this update.

All alerts for Petaluma: http://stopbsl.com/?s=petaluma

Petaluma, CA: Breed-specific MSN under consideration

The Petaluma Animal Services Advisory Committee will be discussing “dog breed-specific mandates on spay/neuter” tonight, Dec 7, at 7:00 PM. The committee meeting will take place in Petaluma City Council chambers, City Hall, 11 English Street, Petaluma, CA 94952. One of the committee members has asked that the committee consider MSN for “pit bull” types.

California municipalities may not pass breed-specific laws, except for breed-specific mandatory spay/neuter. Please note that breed-specific MSN, like any breed-specific law, discriminates against people based on their dog’s looks, and has all the flaws and quandaries of any law based solely on a dog’s appearance. Breed-specific laws of any kind, including BS-MSN, are not an ethical or effective solution.

Please send respectful, informative, and helpful correspondence to the committee, including effective breed-neutral alternatives for their consideration. I wish to re-emphasize respectful. The committee members need your help, not hate.

Contact information for the entire Animal Services Committee can be found here: http://cityofpetaluma.net/cclerk/citycommittees.html
Not all members of the committee have email. Here are the email addresses that are published:
sjdonovan@yahoo.com; nrdyer@comcast.net; headley622@att.net; councilmemberkearney@me.com; jonlong@usa.com; larichardson2@comcast.net; sartainj@gmail.com

Sincere thanks to Gabe Kearney, Petaluma City Councilman and member of the Animal Services Board, for submitting this BSL alert!